If your franchise or distributorship agreement is being ended, or you want to end it, the first question is whether the Franchise Act 1998 applies. For a franchise, section 31 of that Act allows either side to terminate before the expiry date only for good cause, which usually means a breach left unremedied after at least 14 days' written notice. A distributorship is usually governed by its own terms and the Contracts Act 1950.
Is it a franchise or a distributorship?
The label on the document does not decide the question. The Franchise Act 1998 applies to an arrangement that meets the definition of a franchise in section 4 of the Act. In broad terms, that is where one party grants another the right to run a business under its system, to use its mark or other intellectual property, keeps continuing control over how the business is run, and receives payment or other consideration in return.
An ordinary distributorship, where a distributor buys and resells a supplier's products without operating under the supplier's business system, usually falls outside that definition. It is then treated as a commercial contract, governed by its express terms, the Contracts Act 1950 and general contract principles. Some distribution arrangements carry so much control and branding that they may be franchises in substance, so it is worth checking before relying on either set of rules.
Franchise rules that affect termination
Registration
Under section 6 of the Franchise Act 1998, a franchisor must register the franchise with the Registrar of Franchises before operating a franchise business or offering it for sale. A franchisee of a local franchisor must register within fourteen days of signing (section 6B), and a franchisee of a foreign franchisor must register before starting the business (section 6A). Registration problems can affect the parties' positions in a termination dispute.
Minimum term and the cooling-off period
Section 25 provides that a franchise term shall not be less than five years. Under section 33, the term may end earlier only where both parties agree, or where the court decides that conditions in the agreement merit earlier termination.
Separately, section 18(4) requires every franchise agreement to give the franchisee a cooling-off period of not less than seven working days, during which the franchisee may terminate. If the franchisee does so, section 18(5) allows the franchisor to keep only an amount covering its reasonable expenses of preparing the agreement, and the rest of the money paid must be refunded.
Termination only for good cause
Section 31(1) provides that neither the franchisor nor the franchisee may terminate a franchise agreement before its expiry date except for good cause. Under section 31(2), good cause includes a failure to comply with the terms of the franchise agreement, coupled with a failure to remedy the breach within the period stated in a written notice, which must be at least fourteen days.
Section 31(3) lists situations that count as good cause without any notice or chance to remedy, where the other party:
- makes an assignment of the franchise rights for the benefit of creditors, or a similar disposition of the franchise assets;
- becomes bankrupt or insolvent;
- voluntarily abandons the franchised business;
- is convicted of a criminal offence that substantially impairs the goodwill associated with the franchisor's mark or other intellectual property; or
- repeatedly fails to comply with the terms of the franchise agreement.
A termination that does not fit these grounds, or that skips the required notice, is open to challenge. Section 28 also makes void any clause that tries to make a party waive compliance with the Act, so the agreement cannot simply contract out of these rules.
Renewal and extension
Under section 34, a franchisee may apply to extend the franchise term by written notice given at least six months before it expires, and the franchisor must extend unless the franchisee has breached the previous agreement. Section 32 makes it an offence for a franchisor to refuse renewal or extension in certain situations, for example where no written notice of non-renewal was given at least six months before expiry, without buying back the business or making another agreed payment that reflects the loss in its value.
Termination of distributorship agreements
For a distributorship outside the Franchise Act 1998, the right to terminate depends mainly on the contract. Most written distributorship agreements set out how either party may end the agreement, such as by a stated period of notice or for specified breaches.
Where the agreement provides for termination on notice, the terminating party should give the notice period specified and in the form required. Ending the agreement without proper notice may itself be a breach that allows the other side to claim damages.
If the agreement is silent, the court may imply that it can be ended on reasonable notice. What is reasonable depends on the facts, including the length of the relationship, the nature of the business and the investment the distributor has made.
Section 40 of the Contracts Act 1950 provides that when a party to a contract has refused to perform, or disabled himself from performing, his promise in its entirety, the other party may put an end to the contract, unless he has shown by words or conduct that he accepts its continuance.
Post-termination obligations
Both types of agreement usually impose obligations that continue after termination, such as returning manuals, confidential information, branded materials and signage, and stopping use of the principal's trade marks and trade names.
For distributorships, restrictions on competing after termination run into section 28 of the Contracts Act 1950, which makes void, to that extent, every agreement restraining anyone from exercising a lawful profession, trade or business. The main exception covers a seller of the goodwill of a business who agrees not to carry on a similar business within specified local limits, if the court finds those limits reasonable. Outside the statutory exceptions, a restraint is not saved merely by being limited in time or area.
Franchises are different. Section 27 of the Franchise Act 1998 requires the franchisee to give the franchisor a written undertaking that the franchisee, its directors, their spouses and immediate family, and its employees will not carry on a business similar to the franchised business during the term and for two years after expiry or earlier termination. Section 26 requires a similar written undertaking not to disclose information from the operations manual or training for the same period. Failing to comply with either section is an offence. How these provisions apply in a particular case depends on the wording of the undertaking and the facts.
Claims for wrongful termination
Where an agreement is terminated in breach of its terms, or in breach of section 31 for a franchise, the innocent party may bring a claim for damages. Under section 74 of the Contracts Act 1950, damages cover loss that naturally arose in the usual course of things from the breach, or that the parties knew, when they made the contract, to be likely to result from it. Remote and indirect loss is not recoverable.
If the contract names a sum to be paid on breach, section 75 of the Contracts Act 1950 limits recovery to a reasonable amount not exceeding the sum named.
The innocent party may also ask the court for an injunction to restrain continuing breaches, for example to stop the appointment of a replacement distributor in breach of an exclusivity clause that is still in force.
Practical points
- Read the termination, notice and post-termination clauses together, and check whether the Franchise Act 1998 applies.
- Give any notice in the form, to the address and for the period the agreement requires. For a franchise, a notice to remedy must allow at least fourteen days.
- Keep documents that record each breach, each notice and each response.
- Contract claims are generally subject to the six-year limitation period in section 6(1)(a) of the Limitation Act 1953, but contractual notice requirements may apply much earlier.
General information, not legal advice.
Common questions
Can a franchisor end a franchise agreement at any time?
No. Under section 31 of the Franchise Act 1998, neither side may terminate before expiry except for good cause. Usually that means a breach not remedied within a written notice period of at least fourteen days.
Can a franchise be terminated without any notice?
Yes, in limited cases listed in section 31(3), such as bankruptcy or insolvency, abandoning the business, certain criminal convictions, or repeated failure to comply with the agreement.
Are non-compete clauses enforceable after a distributorship ends?
Usually not. Section 28 of the Contracts Act 1950 makes restraints of trade void, with narrow exceptions such as a sale of goodwill. Franchises differ, because section 27 of the Franchise Act 1998 requires a two-year non-compete undertaking.
How much notice is needed to end a distributorship?
Whatever the contract says. If it is silent, the court may imply reasonable notice, judged by the length of the relationship, the nature of the business and the distributor's investment.
Does the Franchise Act 1998 apply to distributorship agreements?
Only if the arrangement meets the Act's definition of a franchise in section 4, such as where the supplier licenses its system and mark and keeps continuing control. An ordinary resale distributorship usually falls outside it.