If an employer has called on an on-demand performance bond, the bank will usually pay unless a court restrains the call. Malaysian courts will step in only where you show clear fraud or a strong prima facie case of unconscionable conduct by the party making the call. Banks often pay within days, so any application to court has to be made promptly.
What is an on-demand performance bond?
An on-demand performance bond (often in the form of a bank guarantee) is an undertaking, usually issued by a bank or insurer, to pay a stated sum to a beneficiary when the beneficiary makes a written demand. It secures the contractor's or supplier's performance of an underlying contract, typically a construction or supply agreement.
Unlike a traditional surety arrangement, an on-demand bond does not require the beneficiary to prove that the contractor has actually breached the underlying contract. Once a demand that complies with the bond's terms is made, the bank pays. That is the commercial bargain the parties struck.
The independence principle
Malaysian courts treat an on-demand performance bond as a contract separate from the underlying building or supply contract. This is called the autonomy or independence principle. The bank's obligation to pay arises from the bond itself, not from what may or may not have happened on site.
Because of this principle, a contractor cannot stop payment simply by arguing that the employer's allegations of defective work are wrong, or that the employer is the one in breach. Those disputes belong to arbitration or litigation on the underlying contract.
Grounds for restraining a call
Malaysian courts recognise only narrow exceptions to the independence principle. A contractor or supplier seeking an injunction to stop the beneficiary calling on, or receiving money under, the bond must show one of the following.
Fraud
Fraud here means, in broad terms, that the beneficiary knows there is no honest basis for the demand. The fraud must be clear on the evidence before the court. A mere allegation of fraud, or a suspicion that the employer is exaggerating its claim, is not enough, and the court will not hold a mini-trial of the underlying contract dispute at the injunction stage.
Unconscionability
In Sumatec Engineering and Construction Sdn Bhd v Malaysian Refining Co Sdn Bhd [2012] 4 MLJ 1, the Federal Court held that unconscionable conduct by the beneficiary is a separate and distinct ground, apart from fraud, for restraining a call on an on-demand bond. The Federal Court approved the approach of the Court of Appeal in Kejuruteraan Bintai Kindenko Sdn Bhd v Nam Fatt Construction Sdn Bhd & Anor [2011] 7 CLJ 442.
The threshold is high. The applicant must put forward manifest or strong evidence, not a bare assertion, amounting to a strong prima facie case of unconscionability. The conduct must be serious enough to "prick the conscience" of a reasonable and sensible person, usually involving unfairness or bad faith. Whether that test is met depends heavily on the facts. In Sumatec itself, the Federal Court accepted the ground in principle but agreed with the Court of Appeal that it had not been proved on the evidence.
Commercial parties are expected to live with the security arrangements they agreed to, and courts do not lightly second-guess a beneficiary's decision to call on a bond.
Applying for an injunction
The usual remedy is an interim injunction under Order 29 of the Rules of Court 2012 restraining the beneficiary from calling on or receiving payment under the bond and, in some cases, restraining the bank from paying.
Timing
Many bonds require the bank to pay promptly after a compliant demand. Once the money is paid out, an injunction to stop the call no longer serves its purpose. The contractor may still pursue the employer under the underlying contract, but recovering money already paid is usually harder and slower than stopping payment in the first place.
Evidence
The application is supported by affidavit evidence. The contractor should put before the court contemporaneous documents, such as correspondence, site records and any written admissions, that make out the required case of fraud or unconscionability. Bare assertions in an affidavit will not be enough.
Undertaking as to damages and balance of convenience
A party seeking an interim injunction is normally required to give an undertaking to make good any loss the other side suffers if the injunction later turns out to have been wrongly granted. The court may also ask for that undertaking to be backed by security. The court will also consider where the balance of convenience lies.
If the injunction is refused
If the court refuses the injunction, the bond will be paid. The contractor's route then lies in the underlying contract: it can pursue arbitration or court proceedings to recover the sum paid out if it shows that the employer was not justified in calling on the bond. That process takes time and carries litigation risk.
Drafting points for contractors
Contractors negotiating construction or supply contracts may wish to consider:
- A clause requiring the employer to give written notice of the alleged default and a chance to remedy it before calling on the bond.
- Limits on when a call may be made, for example only after a determination by the contract administrator or after an adjudication decision.
- A bond amount that is proportionate to the contract and reduces as work progresses.
- Prompt release of the bond after the defects liability period expires.
These provisions do not turn an on-demand bond into a conditional bond, but they can give the contractor a contractual claim against the employer for a call made in breach of them.
Drafting points for employers
Employers relying on performance bonds should check that:
- The bond matches the requirements of the underlying contract.
- The demand procedure is clearly stated, so a compliant demand can be prepared without ambiguity.
- The expiry date extends beyond the end of the defects liability period, with a margin for making a demand.
- Any extension or variation of the underlying contract is reflected in the bond, to avoid arguments that the bond has lapsed.
Key points
An on-demand performance bond is designed to give quick access to funds, and Malaysian courts respect that purpose by restraining calls only in exceptional cases of clear fraud or proven unconscionability. A contractor facing a call it believes is wrongful needs to act promptly, gather documentary evidence and meet a demanding legal threshold. For both sides, careful drafting at the contract stage is the main way to manage the risk.
General information, not legal advice.
Common questions
Can I stop a bond call just because I dispute the employer's allegations?
No. A dispute over the underlying breach is not enough. You must show clear fraud or a strong prima facie case of unconscionable conduct by the party calling on the bond.
What does unconscionable mean for a bond call?
Conduct involving serious unfairness or bad faith that would prick the conscience of a reasonable person. The Federal Court in Sumatec recognised it as a ground separate from fraud, but strong evidence is needed.
How quickly must I act to get an injunction?
Promptly. Many bonds require the bank to pay soon after a compliant demand, and once payment is made an injunction to stop the call no longer helps. Seek advice as soon as you learn of the call.
What happens if the injunction fails and the bank pays?
You can still pursue the employer under the underlying contract, in arbitration or court, if the call was not justified. That route is usually slower than stopping the payment.
Does a conditional bond work differently?
Yes. Under a conditional bond the beneficiary usually has to establish the contractor's default before payment is due. Check the wording carefully, because the label on the document does not decide which type it is.