Under section 351 of the Companies Act 2016, a defendant may apply for an order requiring a company plaintiff to provide security for the defendant's potential costs if the court is satisfied, based on credible testimony, that there is reason to believe the company will be unable to pay those costs should the defence succeed. The court retains discretion and will weigh factors including the merits of the claim, timing of the application, and whether the company's financial difficulties were caused by the defendant's own conduct.

The statutory foundation

Section 351 of the Companies Act 2016 empowers the court to order a company plaintiff to provide security for a defendant's potential costs. The provision applies where it appears, by credible testimony, that there is reason to believe the company will be unable to pay the defendant's costs if the defendant successfully defends the action.

This power exists because a company, unlike a natural person, can be wound up or left without assets, potentially leaving a successful defendant unable to recover anything. The provision balances the defendant's legitimate interest in protection against the company's right of access to justice.

Order 23 of the Rules of Court 2012

Order 23 of the Rules of Court 2012 provides the procedural framework for security for costs applications generally. It sets out how applications are to be made, the court's powers to order security, and the consequences of non-compliance with an order.

Where a company plaintiff is concerned, section 351 of the Companies Act 2016 and Order 23 operate together. The statutory provision establishes the substantive ground specific to companies, while the Rules govern procedural matters.

The threshold: credible testimony of inability to pay

The defendant bears the burden of establishing, through credible testimony, that there is reason to believe the company plaintiff will be unable to pay the defendant's costs if the defence succeeds. This is typically done by affidavit evidence.

Evidence that may support such an application includes:

  • The company's filed financial statements showing a deficiency of assets over liabilities
  • Evidence that the company has ceased trading
  • Unpaid judgment debts against the company
  • The company's own admissions regarding its financial position
  • Winding-up petitions or statutory demands served on the company

Mere assertion is insufficient. The defendant must place concrete material before the court demonstrating a real risk that costs, if awarded, would go unsatisfied.

Factors the court considers in exercising its discretion

Even where the threshold is met, the court retains a discretion whether to order security. Malaysian courts have regard to various factors when deciding whether to exercise this discretion.

The merits of the claim

If the company's claim appears strong on its face, the court may decline to order security or order a reduced amount. Conversely, a claim that appears weak or speculative may weigh in favour of ordering security. The court will not conduct a mini-trial but will consider the apparent strength or weakness of the case.

Whether the defendant caused the company's impecuniosity

If the company's financial difficulties were caused by the very conduct complained of in the action, the court may refuse to order security. It would be unjust to allow a defendant to rely on impecuniosity that the defendant itself brought about.

Timing of the application

An application for security should be made promptly. A defendant who delays without good reason, allowing the litigation to progress and the company to incur substantial expenditure, may find the court less willing to order security. Late applications may be viewed as tactical manoeuvres rather than genuine attempts to obtain protection.

Whether the order would stifle the claim

The court will consider whether ordering security would effectively shut out the company from pursuing a genuine claim. However, unlike with individual plaintiffs, the fact that a company cannot provide security does not automatically mean the application should be refused. The court may enquire whether those standing behind the company—shareholders or directors—could fund security or the litigation itself.

The conduct of the parties

The court may take into account the conduct of both parties in the litigation. Delay, failure to comply with directions, or other conduct affecting the fair and efficient progress of the case may be relevant.

How the amount of security is determined

When ordering security, the court must determine an appropriate quantum. The amount is intended to reflect a reasonable estimate of the defendant's recoverable costs if the defence succeeds.

The court typically considers:

  • The complexity of the case and the anticipated length of trial
  • The nature and volume of the issues to be tried
  • The stage the proceedings have reached
  • Whether security is ordered for the entire action or only up to a particular stage

Security is often ordered in stages—for example, security up to the close of pleadings initially, with liberty to apply for further security thereafter. This approach avoids the need to estimate the entire cost of proceedings at the outset and allows the court to revisit the matter as the case develops.

Forms of security

Security may be provided in various forms. The most common are:

  • Payment into court
  • A bank guarantee from an approved financial institution
  • A bond or undertaking acceptable to the court

The parties may agree on the form of security. Failing agreement, the court will specify what is acceptable.

Consequences of failure to provide security

If a company plaintiff fails to comply with an order for security within the time specified, the defendant may apply for the action to be dismissed or stayed. A stay means the proceedings cannot advance until security is provided. Dismissal brings the action to an end, though it may be possible in some circumstances to apply to set aside the dismissal if security is subsequently provided.

Practical considerations for defendants

A defendant considering an application for security should act promptly once aware of grounds to believe the company plaintiff may be unable to meet an adverse order. Assembling the necessary evidence—such as company searches, filed accounts, and any relevant correspondence—is essential before making the application.

Practical considerations for company plaintiffs

A company facing a security application should be prepared to demonstrate its financial position or to explain how it will meet any adverse order. If the company's impecuniosity results from the defendant's conduct, this should be clearly articulated in the responding evidence.

Common questions

Can a defendant ask for security against any company plaintiff?

Only where there is credible evidence that the company will be unable to pay the defendant's costs if the defence succeeds. A solvent company with sufficient assets would not normally be ordered to provide security.

Does proving impecuniosity guarantee the defendant gets security?

No. The court retains discretion and will consider factors including the merits of the claim, timing of the application, and whether the defendant caused the company's financial difficulties.

What happens if the company cannot provide the security ordered?

The defendant may apply for the proceedings to be stayed or dismissed. A stay halts the action until security is provided; dismissal ends the claim.

Can security be ordered in stages rather than one lump sum?

Yes. Courts often order security up to a particular stage of proceedings, with liberty to apply for further security as the case progresses.

Will an order for security prevent the company from pursuing its claim?

Potentially. If the company and those behind it cannot fund security, the claim may be stayed or dismissed. The court considers this but it does not automatically prevent an order being made.