If your name has been wrongly removed from a company's register of members, or if someone else's name has been wrongly added, the court has the power to order rectification under Section 105 of the Companies Act 2016. This remedy is available to any person aggrieved, any member of the company, or the company itself, and the court may also decide questions of title to shares as part of the application.

What Section 105 provides

Section 105 of the Companies Act 2016 gives the court a specific power to correct errors in the register of members. Under this section, the court may order the register to be rectified if:

  • The name of any person is, without sufficient cause, entered in or omitted from the register of members
  • Default is made or unnecessary delay takes place in entering on the register the fact of any person having ceased to be a member

The section also empowers the court to decide any question relating to the title of a person who is a party to the application to have that person's name entered in or omitted from the register. This is significant because it means the court can resolve the underlying ownership dispute as part of the rectification proceedings.

Who may apply for rectification

Section 105 sets out three categories of applicants:

  • The person aggrieved
  • Any member of the company
  • The company itself

A person is aggrieved if the error in the register affects their rights or interests. This typically includes someone whose name has been wrongly removed, someone who claims to be entitled to shares that are registered in another person's name, or someone whose shareholding has been diluted by an improper allotment to others.

Typical disputes that lead to rectification applications

Forged or disputed share transfer forms

One of the most common situations involves a share transfer that the registered holder claims they never signed. If a transfer form bearing a forged signature is lodged with the company and the company registers the transferee as the new member, the original shareholder can apply under Section 105 to have their name restored to the register.

In such cases, the applicant will typically need to adduce evidence that the signature is not theirs. This may involve calling a handwriting analyst or simply giving direct evidence that they did not sign the document and did not authorise anyone else to sign on their behalf.

Transfers without valid consideration

Another frequent dispute arises when shares are transferred but the agreed consideration is never paid. The position here is more nuanced. A share transfer may be valid even if consideration has not been paid, depending on the terms of the agreement between the parties. However, if the transfer was conditional upon payment, and payment was never made, the transferor may argue that the condition was never satisfied and the transfer should not have been registered.

The court will examine the actual agreement between the parties to determine whether payment was a condition precedent to the transfer or merely an obligation that the transferee was required to perform after the transfer.

Shares transferred in breach of restrictions

Many company constitutions contain restrictions on the transfer of shares, such as pre-emption rights requiring shares to be offered first to existing members. If a transfer is registered in breach of such restrictions, an aggrieved member may apply for rectification.

Improper allotments

Rectification may also be sought where new shares have been allotted without proper authority or in breach of the directors' duties. If the allotment was made for an improper purpose or without the necessary shareholder approval, the resulting entries in the register may be challenged.

Evidence required in a rectification application

The applicant must prove on the balance of probabilities that the entry in the register is wrong or that an entry that should be there is missing. The specific evidence will depend on the nature of the dispute:

  • For forgery claims: evidence that the signature is not genuine, such as testimony from the alleged signatory and potentially opinion evidence on handwriting
  • For unpaid consideration: the agreement between the parties, evidence of non-payment, and evidence as to whether payment was a condition of the transfer
  • For breach of constitutional restrictions: the company's constitution and evidence showing the restrictions were not complied with
  • For improper allotments: board minutes, shareholder resolutions, and evidence of the purpose for which the allotment was made

The applicant should also exhibit a copy of the current register of members showing the entry complained of.

The relationship between the register and SSM records

Companies are required to lodge information about changes in shareholdings with the Companies Commission of Malaysia (SSM). The SSM records are derived from returns lodged by the company and are not themselves the register of members.

When the court orders rectification of the register of members under Section 105, the company will then need to lodge the appropriate returns with SSM to update the public records. The court order operates on the company's own register; the SSM records are updated as a consequence.

It is worth noting that discrepancies between a company's internal register and the SSM records can themselves be evidence that something has gone wrong with the recording of share transfers.

Orders the court may make

If the court is satisfied that rectification is warranted, it may order:

  • The register to be rectified by adding or removing names
  • Payment by the company of any damages sustained by any party aggrieved

The court has a broad discretion as to the terms of any rectification order. In appropriate cases, the court may also make consequential orders, such as requiring the company to lodge amended returns with SSM.

Practical considerations

Before commencing court proceedings, it is usually sensible to write to the company and the other parties setting out the basis for the claim and requesting that the register be corrected voluntarily. This correspondence may be relevant to questions of conduct if the matter proceeds to court.

The company itself is often named as a party to rectification proceedings, even if the real dispute is between shareholders, because the company maintains the register and will need to give effect to any order.

Section 105 proceedings are distinct from proceedings under Section 346 of the Companies Act 2016, which deals with oppression. While both remedies may be relevant in a shareholder dispute, they serve different purposes and have different requirements. Rectification is concerned with correcting the register; oppression is concerned with conduct that is oppressive to members or in disregard of their interests.

General information, not legal advice.

Common questions

Who can apply to the court to rectify the register of members?

Under Section 105 of the Companies Act 2016, an application may be made by the person aggrieved, any member of the company, or the company itself.

Can I get rectification if my signature on a share transfer was forged?

Yes. If you can prove the signature was not yours and you did not authorise the transfer, the court may order rectification to restore your name to the register.

Does the court order automatically update SSM records?

No. The court order rectifies the company's own register. The company must then lodge the appropriate returns with SSM to update the public records.

What if shares were transferred but I was never paid?

The court will examine whether payment was a condition of the transfer. If it was, and payment was not made, rectification may be ordered.

Is rectification the same as an oppression claim?

No. Section 105 rectification corrects errors in the register. Section 346 oppression addresses conduct that is unfairly prejudicial to members. They are separate remedies.