When you acquire a Malaysian company by share sale or asset sale, the seller typically gives warranties about the business. If those warranties turn out to be false, the buyer may have a claim for breach of contract, but must navigate disclosure letters, contractual caps, time-bars and strict notice requirements in the sale agreement.
How disputes arise after completion
Most acquisitions of Malaysian SMEs proceed by way of a share sale (where the buyer acquires shares in the target company) or an asset sale (where the buyer acquires the business assets directly). In either structure, the sale and purchase agreement will contain warranties—statements of fact by the seller about the target business.
Disputes typically surface in the months or years after completion, when the buyer discovers matters that contradict the warranties. Common examples include undisclosed liabilities, overstated receivables, missing assets, pending litigation, or tax exposures that were not revealed during due diligence.
Warranties and indemnities: the distinction
A warranty is a contractual statement of fact. If the warranty is untrue, the buyer has a claim for breach of contract. The buyer must prove the breach and, in principle, may recover damages for the loss that naturally arose from the breach (section 74 of the Contracts Act 1950), often measured by the drop in value of what was acquired.
An indemnity is a promise to hold the buyer harmless against a specified liability or loss. If the indemnified event occurs, the buyer can recover on a ringgit-for-ringgit basis without having to prove loss in the same way as a warranty claim. Indemnities are often used for known risks, such as a pending tax audit or identified litigation.
The practical difference is significant. Warranty claims require the buyer to establish the measure of loss. Indemnity claims entitle the buyer to recover the actual amount of the liability, subject to any contractual limits.
The role of the disclosure letter
A disclosure letter is delivered by the seller at or before completion. It sets out matters that qualify the warranties—essentially, exceptions to the seller's statements. If a matter is properly disclosed, the buyer cannot later claim for breach of the warranty to which that disclosure relates.
Disputes often turn on whether a disclosure was sufficiently specific. General or vague disclosures may not protect the seller if they did not fairly inform the buyer of the issue. The drafting of both the warranties and the disclosure letter is therefore critical.
Limitation of liability clauses
Sale agreements almost always contain provisions limiting the seller's exposure. These may include:
- Financial caps: a maximum aggregate liability for warranty claims, often set by reference to the amount paid for the shares or business.
- De minimis thresholds: a minimum claim size below which no claim can be brought.
- Basket or aggregate thresholds: requiring claims to exceed a cumulative amount before the buyer can recover.
- Time limits: a period within which claims must be notified, and sometimes a period within which proceedings must be started (see the section on time limits below for why the second kind needs care in Malaysia).
- Exclusions: for consequential loss, loss of profit, or other categories of damage.
Caps, thresholds and exclusions are generally upheld under Malaysian law if they are clearly worded. Courts read them strictly against the party relying on them, and a term with an object that is unlawful or against public policy is void under section 24 of the Contracts Act 1950.
Notice requirements
Most sale agreements impose strict notice requirements. The buyer must notify the seller of any claim within a specified period after becoming aware of it. The notice must typically contain prescribed particulars: the nature of the claim, the warranty or indemnity relied upon, and the amount claimed (or a reasonable estimate).
Failure to comply with notice requirements may bar the claim. Whether it does depends on the exact wording, so read the clause the day you suspect a problem rather than waiting until you have the full figures.
Time limits for bringing claims
Contractual time limits in the sale agreement govern when claims must be notified. These are separate from limitation periods under statute.
Under the Limitation Act 1953, section 6(1)(a), an action founded on contract must be brought within six years from the date on which the cause of action accrued. For warranty claims, this is typically the date of the breach—often the date of completion when the warranty was given and was false.
Sale agreements usually set much shorter contractual periods. Malaysian law treats two kinds of clause differently. Section 29 of the Contracts Act 1950 makes an agreement void to the extent that it limits the time within which a party may enforce its rights through the courts, so a bare clause saying proceedings must be started within, say, 12 months may not bind the buyer. A clause that requires notice of a claim within a set period, or that says the seller's liability ends after a set period, is a different matter and may still defeat a late claim. Which kind of clause you have turns on its wording, so the safe course is to treat every contractual deadline as binding and act well inside it.
Conduct of claims and disputes
Sale agreements often contain provisions governing how claims are to be pursued. These may include:
- Requirements for the buyer to allow the seller to participate in the defence of third-party claims.
- Restrictions on the buyer settling or compromising claims without the seller's consent.
- Dispute resolution mechanisms, such as negotiation, mediation, or arbitration, before court proceedings may be commenced.
Failure to follow these procedures may affect the buyer's ability to recover.
Proving and quantifying the claim
For a warranty claim, the buyer must prove that the warranty was untrue at the time it was given (usually completion) and that the buyer has suffered loss as a result. The measure of damages is typically the difference between the value of what was acquired if the warranty had been true, and its actual value given the breach.
For an indemnity claim, the buyer must prove that the indemnified event has occurred and the amount of the liability. The focus is on the actual loss suffered, not on comparing values.
Proper record-keeping and documentation are essential. The buyer should preserve evidence of the breach and all expenses and liabilities incurred as a result.
Practical considerations for buyers and sellers
Buyers should review the sale agreement carefully before completion to understand the scope of the warranties, the effect of the disclosure letter, and the limitations on claims. After completion, buyers should monitor the business for matters that may give rise to a claim and act promptly if issues arise.
Sellers should ensure that disclosures are specific and comprehensive, and that the limitation provisions adequately protect their position. Sellers should also retain copies of all transaction documents and respond carefully to any claim notifications.
General information, not legal advice.
Common questions
What is the difference between a warranty claim and an indemnity claim?
A warranty claim requires the buyer to prove breach and loss. An indemnity allows recovery of the actual liability on a ringgit-for-ringgit basis once the indemnified event occurs, without proving loss in the same way.
Can a disclosure letter prevent me from claiming?
Yes. If a matter was properly disclosed against a warranty, the buyer generally cannot claim for that issue. The disclosure must be sufficiently specific to qualify the warranty.
How long do I have to bring a warranty claim?
Check the sale agreement first: notice deadlines are usually much shorter than the six years allowed for contract claims under section 6(1)(a) of the Limitation Act 1953. A clause that only shortens the time to sue may be void under section 29 of the Contracts Act 1950.
What happens if I miss a notice deadline?
You may lose the claim, depending on how the clause is worded. Send a notice that follows the agreement's required form and address as soon as you suspect a breach.
Are caps on liability enforceable in Malaysia?
Generally yes, if clearly drafted. Courts read them strictly, and a term that is unlawful or against public policy is void under section 24 of the Contracts Act 1950.