Yes, if you sell a business together with its goodwill. Section 28 of the Contracts Act 1950 makes most restraints of trade void, but its first exception lets a seller of goodwill agree not to carry on a similar business within specified local limits that the court considers reasonable, for as long as the buyer carries on a like business there.

The general rule: restraint of trade is void

Section 28 of the Contracts Act 1950 provides that every agreement by which anyone is restrained from exercising a lawful profession, trade or business of any kind is void to that extent. Malaysian courts have held that, unlike the English approach, there is no general test of reasonableness to save a restraint: if a clause is a restraint of trade and none of the three statutory exceptions applies, it is void. That is why the exceptions matter so much in a business sale.

For non-compete clauses in employment contracts, see our article on whether non-compete clauses are enforceable in Malaysia. This article deals with the sale of a business.

Exception 1: sale of goodwill

Exception 1 to section 28 says that one who sells the goodwill of a business may agree with the buyer to refrain from carrying on a similar business within specified local limits, so long as the buyer, or anyone deriving title to the goodwill from the buyer, carries on a like business there. The proviso adds that the limits must appear to the court reasonable, having regard to the nature of the business.

The reason is simple. A buyer who pays for goodwill, meaning the customer relationships and reputation of the business, gets little if the seller can open a competing business next door the following week.

Exception 2: partners on dissolution

Exception 2 allows partners, upon or in anticipation of the dissolution of a partnership, to agree that some or all of them will not carry on a similar business within the same kind of local limits. A partner selling out on dissolution should therefore look at Exception 2 as well as Exception 1.

When goodwill is really being sold

The exception is most clearly available on a sale of a business as a going concern with its goodwill. Points to watch:

  • If only some assets are sold and goodwill is not part of the deal, the exception may not apply and the restraint may be void.
  • On a sale of shares, the goodwill belongs to the company, not to the selling shareholder. Whether a selling shareholder's non-compete falls within Exception 1 is less settled, so the documents should be drafted with care and advice taken.
  • The sale agreement should state expressly that goodwill is sold and identify the business concerned.

Area, activity and duration

Area. The restraint must be within specified local limits, and those limits must appear reasonable to the court given the nature of the business. An area that matches where the business actually traded is easier to defend than a wider one.

Activity. The exception covers carrying on a similar business. A clause stopping the seller from carrying on any business at all goes beyond that, and a clause aimed at stopping the seller from taking a job with a competitor may fall outside the exception.

Duration. Section 28 ties the restraint to the period during which the buyer carries on a like business in the area; it does not set a maximum period. Parties often agree a fixed period for certainty. If the buyer stops carrying on a like business in the area, the seller's restraint may fall away.

Drafting points for sellers

  • Keep the restricted business narrow, so you can still pursue unrelated ventures.
  • Agree a clear geographic boundary that reflects where the business traded.
  • Agree a fixed period rather than an open-ended restraint.
  • Be clear whether the restraint covers you only, or also companies you control.

Drafting points for buyers

  • Make sure the agreement expressly includes goodwill in the sale.
  • Define the restricted activity so that it catches competition in substance, including through a company or a different trading name.
  • Describe the area precisely; vague descriptions create doubt.
  • A clause saying the parties consider the restraint reasonable may help show intention, but it does not bind the court.

When a restraint may still fail

  • Goodwill was not genuinely part of the transaction.
  • The area goes beyond what the court considers reasonable for the business.
  • The restricted activity goes beyond a similar business.
  • The buyer has stopped carrying on a like business in the area.

Review the non-compete wording before the sale completes, so that it reflects the commercial deal and fits within section 28. This article covers Malaysian law only. General information, not legal advice.

Common questions

Are non-compete clauses valid when selling a business in Malaysia?

They can be. Section 28 of the Contracts Act 1950 voids most restraints of trade, but Exception 1 allows a seller of goodwill to agree not to carry on a similar business within reasonable specified local limits.

How long can the restraint last?

Section 28 sets no maximum. The restraint lasts while the buyer carries on a like business in the area. Many agreements also set a fixed period for certainty.

What happens if the buyer stops running the business?

The exception applies only so long as the buyer, or someone deriving title to the goodwill from the buyer, carries on a like business in the area. If that stops, the restraint may no longer bind the seller.

Can the restraint cover the whole of Malaysia?

Possibly, if the business genuinely traded nationwide. The court must consider the limits reasonable given the nature of the business, so a wider area than the business served is at risk.

Does the exception apply if I sell only assets, not goodwill?

Probably not. Exception 1 is about a sale of goodwill. Without goodwill, a non-compete clause may be void under the general rule in section 28.