If you have a strong claim against someone and solid evidence that they may move or hide their assets before you can enforce a judgment, you can apply to the High Court for a Mareva injunction to freeze those assets while the case goes on. You must show a good arguable case, assets the order can reach, and a real risk that the assets will be dissipated. You must also make full disclosure to the court and give an undertaking as to damages.
What is a Mareva injunction?
A Mareva injunction, also called a freezing order, is an interlocutory court order that prohibits a defendant from disposing of, dealing with or reducing the value of their assets up to a specified amount. The order takes its name from an English case and is a well-established remedy in Malaysia.
Its purpose is to stop a defendant from frustrating the enforcement of a future judgment. Without such an order, a claimant might succeed at trial only to find that the assets which could have satisfied the judgment are gone.
Where the court's power comes from
The High Court's power to grant a Mareva injunction comes from section 25(2) of the Courts of Judicature Act 1964, read with paragraph 6 of the Schedule to that Act, which gives the court power to provide for the interim preservation of property, including by injunction. The Supreme Court confirmed that Malaysian courts have this jurisdiction in Aspatra Sdn Bhd v Bank Bumiputra Malaysia Bhd [1988] 1 MLJ 97. Applications for injunctions are made under Order 29 rule 1 of the Rules of Court 2012.
What you must show the court
A Mareva injunction is an exceptional remedy and Malaysian courts do not grant it lightly. In Creative Furnishing Sdn Bhd v Wong Koi [1989] 2 MLJ 153, the Supreme Court, following Aspatra, said the applicant must show a good arguable case, that the defendant has assets within the jurisdiction, and a real risk that those assets will be dissipated or removed before judgment, supported by solid evidence.
A good arguable case
You must show a good arguable case against the defendant. That is more than a claim which is merely capable of argument, but you do not have to prove that you will win. The court looks at whether the claim, on the evidence before it, has real substance.
Assets the order can reach
You should give the court whatever evidence you have of the defendant's assets in Malaysia, such as bank accounts, land, shares or business assets. Usually the order is limited to assets in Malaysia. In exceptional cases Malaysian courts have granted worldwide orders that also cover assets abroad, for example the High Court in Metrowangsa Asset Management Sdn Bhd v Ahmad b Hj Hassan [2005] 1 MLJ 654, but the court takes a more careful approach before doing so.
A real risk of dissipation
This is often the hardest requirement. You must show a real risk that the defendant will move, hide or dispose of assets so that a judgment cannot be enforced. A mere fear or suspicion is not enough. The court looks for evidence such as assets already being transferred, unexplained movements of funds after the dispute arose, dishonest conduct connected with the claim, or the use of companies to put assets out of reach.
Full and frank disclosure
Mareva applications are usually made without notice to the defendant, so the applicant has a strict duty to disclose all material facts to the court, including facts that do not help the application and the answers the defendant is likely to give. If this duty is breached, the court may set the injunction aside even if it would otherwise have been justified.
An undertaking as to damages
The applicant must give the court an undertaking to pay any damages the court orders if the injunction later turns out to have been wrongly granted and has caused the defendant loss. This is not a formality. Where there is doubt about the applicant's ability to honour the undertaking, the court may require it to be backed by security, such as a payment into court or a bank guarantee.
Applying without notice
Applications are often made without notice to the defendant, because a defendant who learns of the application in advance may move assets before the order is made. The application is made by notice of application supported by an affidavit, which must explain why notice was not given and set out the material facts fairly.
If the court grants an injunction without notice, it will fix a further hearing at which the defendant can ask the court to set aside or vary the order. Acting promptly once you have evidence of the risk matters, because unexplained delay can suggest that the risk is not real.
What the order does and does not do
A Mareva injunction restrains the defendant from dealing with their assets up to a stated amount, usually linked to the value of the claim. A typical order:
- Prohibits the defendant from removing assets from Malaysia, or disposing of, dealing with or reducing the value of their assets within Malaysia, up to that amount
- Allows the defendant to spend reasonable sums on ordinary living expenses, ordinary business dealings and legal advice and representation
- Requires the defendant to disclose their assets
- Allows third parties such as banks to be told of the order
A Mareva injunction does not give the applicant security over the defendant's assets. It does not create a charge or lien, and it does not give the applicant priority over other creditors. It preserves the position until judgment.
Risks for the applicant
Under the undertaking as to damages, you may have to pay the defendant for loss caused by the injunction if it is later set aside or your claim fails, for example if frozen bank accounts disrupted the defendant's business.
If you did not make full and frank disclosure, the court may set the injunction aside and make adverse orders against you. Courts guard closely against misuse of this remedy.
A Mareva injunction does not mean you will recover your debt. The defendant may still have a defence to your claim, and other creditors may have claims on the same assets.
Practical points
Before applying, gather as much evidence as you can about the defendant's assets and conduct, and support the affidavit with documents where possible. Be realistic about the strength of your claim and the risks involved. A Mareva injunction is not suitable for every unpaid debt; it is meant for cases where there is a genuine, evidenced risk that the defendant will frustrate enforcement.
General information, not legal advice.
Common questions
Can I freeze a debtor's assets before I have a judgment?
Yes, if you meet the requirements. The High Court can grant a Mareva injunction restraining a defendant from dissipating assets while your claim is decided, but you need a good arguable case and solid evidence of a real risk of dissipation.
What happens if I fail to disclose relevant facts to the court?
The court may set the injunction aside, even if it would otherwise have been granted, and may make adverse orders against you. Disclose unfavourable facts as well as favourable ones.
Does a Mareva injunction give me priority over other creditors?
No. It preserves assets until judgment but does not create a charge or any other security. Other creditors with valid claims may still be paid ahead of you.
Can the defendant still spend money while the order is in force?
Usually yes. A typical order allows reasonable spending on ordinary living expenses, ordinary business dealings and legal advice and representation, often within stated limits.
Can a Malaysian court freeze assets outside Malaysia?
In exceptional cases, yes. Malaysian courts have granted worldwide Mareva injunctions covering assets abroad, but most orders are limited to assets in Malaysia.